One year, my (very successful) brother rented a house in Some Blue Hive State, so his family could summer there. I received an invitation, that should I wrangle the time off of work, and my own transportation, I’d have a spot to stay and join in the merriment.
TDW was interested, and so I arranged vacation, and purchased plane tickets. One car rental later, and we were off!
My brother is an alumnus of an Eastern Sophisticated University, and, therefore, all of his college buddies are, as well. That trends towards them also being of the Blue Hive Borg, where, evidently, “assimilation is Mandatory!”
All these fellows are attorneys, and, generally, pretty smart. No surprise there, right? So, one evening, after consumption of Tax Stamped Beverages, well, one guy (let’s call him Bob, “not-his-real-name”) overheard The Darling Wife regaling me with her recent visit to an Unnamed Flyover State Gun Show, wherein she had purchased an AR pattern rifle, in 6.8 Rem Special. Good News: She was very excited at her selection, describing her new rifle as “Pretty!”. Bad news: Have you PRICED 6.8 Rem Spl ammo lately? Holy Stool, that is expensive ammunition. Not as pricey as H & H .375, or .416 Rigby, I’ll grant you, but pretty spendy against sixty-cent-a-round .223 ammo.
So, Bob told us what his thoughts about that were. That is, if you could characterize him as “thinking” on that subject. “Man, they ought outlaw gun shows! That gun show loophole is awful!”
I know a thing or two about guns, as does The Darling Wife. She had, after all, just the preceding month gone to a gun show, and purchased a rifle. Indeed, in terms of contemporaneous experience based knowledge, she might qualify, within the confines of that house, as a subject matter expert.
Therefore, I asked Bob, “Oh, really? What is the ‘gun show loophole’, and what is the most objectionable part of it, in your view?”
He apparently was not one to let ignorance of the subject get in the way of a good opportunity to let his “woke” flag fly. “Why, it shouldn’t be allowed that simply anyone can just walk right in to a gun show, and just buy any sort of gun that they want, and then just walk right out!”
He was gonna repeat himself. “Any sort of drunken lout, or mental defective, or terrorist, or mass shooter, can just walk into any gun show, buy any sort of mass murder machine that they want, and waltz out! No background check, no permit, no nothing!”
I turned to My Darling Bride, and said, “Honey, didn’t you just buy a rifle at a gun show a couple of weeks ago? Why don’t you tell Bob, here, how that worked?”
She smiled sweetly at me, and turned to Bob. “Well, I paid my admission, I walked the aisles until I found that rifle. It looked so pretty, I thought that it ought to be my first AR. I negotiated a price with the seller. He then needed my picture ID, as well as my concealed carry license. He called the National Instant Check System with my information, and got an approval. He recorded the approval serial number, and then I had to complete a form 4473 before we could complete the sale.”
I invited her to be more detailed in her tutorial for Bob. “So, Honey, what’s a ‘Form 4473’?”
“Well, it is a sworn statement, under penalties of both perjury as well as violation of the federal Gun Control Act, that I’m not a felon, fugitive from justice, mentally ill, an illegal alien, have never been convicted of a crime of domestic violence. There’s a couple of other reasons that I could be disqualified, but they are all listed right there on the form. No sale can move forward without that form.”
Bob could not contain his superior expertise any longer. “That’s just wrong! None of that is required!”
I turned to him. “Really? Why don’t you tell us how it went, the last time YOU purchased a gun at a gun show?”
He looked at me, surprised. “I have never bought any sort of gun, ever! I do not own a gun!”
I feigned surprise. “Really? So, just how did you come by your expertise regarding how things really happen in a gun show, such as to contradict my wife’s recent, personal experience in a gun show? Buying a gun, no less?”
“I read it in the New York Times! They said that’s how it works!”
I looked at my wife, and she at me. I continued. “So, let me see if I heard you correctly. You have never bought any gun, ever, anywhere. You read some bullshit in the New York Times, and that is canonical, for some reason. Based on some perhaps third, maybe fourth hand story, that you think you remember reading, in that noted journal of all things firearms, The New York Times, you are in a solid position to tell my adult wife, sitting right here, that things that she, in fact, and in her own direct testimony actually, really, and recently experienced, did not actually experience. Now, that means that you are either telling me my wife will lie, smiling all the while, to your face, or she is so stupid or mentally defective that she cannot tell what she actually did, at a gun show, buying a gun. Now, mind you, she successfully passed the training to qualify for, and the background check to be issued, a license to carry a concealed handgun from The Un-Named Flyover State. So, pray tell, on what basis does your superior intellect and greater knowledge in All Things Gun, lead you to accuse my wife of imbecility, or lying to your face? Please, go slowly, and show your work!”
At this point, Bob had the wit to stammer, and not answer my questions. My brother, wisely, diverted my attention with some query of firearms law esoterica.
So, therefore, I did not break a stein over Bob’s head.
Although, I still wonder if it might have improved either his manners, or his intellect. Or, perhaps, both.
4 thoughts on ““The Gun Show Loophole!””
Pray tell, does Bobert have any clue as to the fact that he avoided a remedial ass-whupping by your brother’s good wit and your desire not to bloody up the rented premises? Or is he still sailing Clueless Lake?
Sailing. Winds of ignorance in his sail of arrogant cluelessness.
So… let me see. Lawyer. Which requires knowledge of the Law. And he’s basing his legal opinion on a newspaper article he thinks he remembers?
And people wonder why so many of us hate… lawyers. And failed lawyers that become politicians who create laws that suck. And lawyers that become judges who don’t follow… the law but only their feelings because they are wise people of minority origin or something.
Law. Not hard. Yes/No, Pass/Fail. If it is a grey area law, kill the law, or fix the law.
It’s not hard. The law that is. After all, it’s not like you need a science or math background to become a lawyer.
Beans: Yep. In addition, there’s this thing: “legal specialties”.
Corp lawyer, why not have him defend you in court over your use-of-lethal-force beef? After all, it’s not as if there’s nearly a century of statutes and case law regarding firearms…no, wait, THERE IS!